Clark engineers

Catastrophic failure with death

One 20,000-gallon tank 12-ft diameter storing ammonium sulfite at an average laminate temperature of 105 degrees F. to 130 degrees F. with a specific gravity of 1.05 was changed to a more severe environment of ammonium sulfite and ammonium bisulfite in equilibrium operating at 180 degrees F with a specific gravity of 1.27. The tank was operated for 8 years with the initial environment. After setting idle for two years, the  tank was sold to a new company which changed the operating conditions. After an additional 10 years of service at the more severe conditions, the tank failed catastrophically killing one person who had noticed a leak and closed a valve on the tank.

A forensic investigation revealed the following:

The original design called for a dual resin system, but this was not done. The new environment and higher operating temperature was much more severe. The new company added 2 inches of foam insulation to the tank causing the average laminate temperature to be about 50 degrees F. higher. Failure occurred at a manway that had been moved and reinstalled, by popping out while operating full, resulting in the tank imploding due to the quick discharge by pulling a vacuum on this tank.

Lessons Learned

  1. Always conduct a thorough review of the tank design and construction before changing service.
  2. Repairs and modifications should be done only be well-qualified and experienced FRP technicians using correct resin and fiberglass reinforcing that are appropriate for this environment.
  3. Contact the manufacturer for approval of new service and/or if not available, engage the service of a well-qualified consultant to review and make recommendations.
Highly deteriorated liner
Failed surface back of manway
Side bottom drain inside - highly deteriorated
Failed surface on tank at manway